EA sports has done it again. The NHL series has, in my mind, far outshined any other franchise in video game history, including the ever popular Madden games. I've played the EA NHL games since the Sega Genisis, and I've rarely been disappointed. I will admit a couple of times they pretty much cut and pasted the code without much improvement over the previous season. That may be what happened here, but since I never played the '00 version, I can't speak to that. What I can say is that even if you ave the '00 version, the updated rosters and two expansion teams make this a good buy, for as cheap as it can be found.
Whats great about this game? The EA NHL series has a great track record. You know what you are getting into when you get this game. This is far and away one of the best games to play with mutiple people. I truely believe there is no greater head to head video sports game to play. You can get blown out in Madden, and the other team can start running the clock on you, but you're never out of time (until the last minute) in NHL. Also, you can plug in up to 8 controlers with a multi-tap and get a whole group going. See how easy it is to score then.
Speaking of which, some reviews you read make it sound impossible to score, some make it sound like every shot goes in. Whats the real deal you may be wondering? It depends greatly on your skill level (obviously), and wether or not you use line changes. Of course if you only play your best players for the whole game, and you play with Detroit, you're going to score a lot of goals, but is that realistic anyway? If you play at the rookie level, just about any one timer will go in, plus a variety of other shot types. At the most difficult level, it is a challenge to score (at least for those who don't play it 24/7 to figure out all the tricks), and I played in far too many 1-0 or 1-1 games for my preference. At the second hardest level, you can play a good challenging game against the computer, if you take a team with a less than stellar goalie. But the true fun is playing against/with other people. Try mastering the one timer with a buddy, instead of just yourself, then you will have truely enjoyed this game.
As for the franchise mode, there are good points and bad points. The good points is that it track lifetime stats for all players. You can see who the leading scorer is after five seasons. It has a complete set of post season awards, and it always feel great to see your players face one the awards screen after a long season. However, I did find the player management aspects of the franchise mode lacking a certain amount of realistic control. First, one player becomes a free agent from your team every year. Only one. There's no sense of contracts, or salary cap, or anything of that nature. You just randomly lose one player each year. Then when signing free agents, it appears that only good teams can sign good free agents. I won the Stanly Cup with the Wild, but I couldn't sign a single free agent. Then you only draft one player. You may also get a player or two that retires. There are also next to zero free agents available to sign during a season. Overall, I feel that aspect needs improvement, which I fear will never happen as the NHL series may have come to an end for PS1 (now I REALLY need an Xbox).
Pros:
-Proven game quality that dates back to early 90s
-Wide range of difficulty for beginers and experienced gamers
-Great for multi tap and up to 8 players
-Best hockey game on the planet for PS1 (no '02 for PS1?)
-The bets (in my opinion) sports game to play head to head
Cons:
-Franchise format needs work
-The end of the road?